Issues with SSL

I have a private SSL I bought through GoDaddy (very cheap).  I host through Hostgator.  What I want is the entire site to be under the security.  I finally got my certs in line and installed.  When I go to my site www.josiahfoundation.com it does what it supposed to do by going to https:// but I get the following IE message below before the site will show up.

Security Inforamtion
This page contains both secure and nonsecure items.
Do you want to display the nonsecure items?

YES - NO - More info

Usually a site will pull up with some items missing but in my case the entire site is not shown till "YES" is selected.  I see this a lot when using PayPal because of an image not being on a secure site but in my case, the entire site should be under the security.

When I log into the admin panel I get the same message.  However, half the admin panel shows up until I click "YES", then the entire thing is displayed.  Everything below the Awaiting Moderation title is gone till I choose "YES".

Any help would be appreciated.  Thanks in advance.